S2 EP7 - ‘A Man Without Honor.’

[AdmiralDigby]

Does this season suck because they are deviating so much from the books or am I just expecting too much (like it to be as awesome as last year)?

This season does not suck .
Unless awesome is the new hand washing .

I've been entertained, but it's been a bit slow. Just too much story to fit into 10 episodes. Perhaps they can break up the next book.

The Icelandic scenery was quite stunning.

[spoiler]ps. Knowing that the Shadow creature was not revealed in the book like it was in the show, wow. That would have added to the creepy factor.[/spoiler]

Shadow baby ?

Creepifying .

[AdmiralDigby]

Upon second viewing

[spoiler]Will Catelyn be the one who severs Jamie's hand ? She asked for Brienne's sword[/spoiler]

[Spooky]

Upon second viewing

[spoiler]Will Catelyn be the one who severs Jamie's hand ? She asked for Brienne's sword[/spoiler]

Maybe I am remembering wrong, but...

[spoiler]Didn't she do the same thing in the book and then cut him free and sent him with Brienne  as an escort to trade him for the girls? I thought a chapter ended with her asking for a sword and then the it is revealed that she cut him free with it?[/spoiler]

[AdmiralDigby]

Upon second viewing

[spoiler]Will Catelyn be the one who severs Jamie's hand ? She asked for Brienne's sword[/spoiler]

Maybe I am remembering wrong, but...

[spoiler]Didn't she do the same thing in the book and then cut him free and sent him with Brienne  as an escort to trade him for the girls? I thought a chapter ended with her asking for a sword and then the it is revealed that she cut him free with it?[/spoiler]

[spoiler]I know she lets Jamie go . I'm just thinking it's hard to cut a chain with a sword . I can see how the telescoping of certain plotlines might lead to a maimed Jaimie under Brienne's escort . Kinda hope I'm wrong , but either way I'll trust to the showrunners[/spoiler]

[Spooky]

Upon second viewing

[spoiler]Will Catelyn be the one who severs Jamie's hand ? She asked for Brienne's sword[/spoiler]

Maybe I am remembering wrong, but...

[spoiler]Didn't she do the same thing in the book and then cut him free and sent him with Brienne  as an escort to trade him for the girls? I thought a chapter ended with her asking for a sword and then the it is revealed that she cut him free with it?[/spoiler]

[spoiler]I know she lets Jamie go . I'm just thinking it's hard to cut a chain with a sword . I can see how the telescoping of certain plotlines might lead to a maimed Jaimie under Brienne's escort . Kinda hope I'm wrong , but either way I'll trust to the showrunners[/spoiler]

[spoiler]They have mentioned the Brotherhood several times on the show now, so I would hope that they keep the story line intact and have the Kingslayer and Lady Tarth get captured by them and have Vargo Hoat order Jamie's behanding.[/spoiler]

[AdmiralDigby]

Upon second viewing

[spoiler]Will Catelyn be the one who severs Jamie's hand ? She asked for Brienne's sword[/spoiler]

Maybe I am remembering wrong, but...

[spoiler]Didn't she do the same thing in the book and then cut him free and sent him with Brienne  as an escort to trade him for the girls? I thought a chapter ended with her asking for a sword and then the it is revealed that she cut him free with it?[/spoiler]

[spoiler]I know she lets Jamie go . I'm just thinking it's hard to cut a chain with a sword . I can see how the telescoping of certain plotlines might lead to a maimed Jaimie under Brienne's escort . Kinda hope I'm wrong , but either way I'll trust to the showrunners[/spoiler]

[spoiler]They have mentioned the Brotherhood several times on the show now, so I would hope that they keep the story line intact and have the Kingslayer and Lady Tarth get captured by them and have Vargo Hoat order Jamie's behanding.[/spoiler]

[spoiler]I hope so [/spoiler]

[Eric]

[spoiler]I know she lets Jamie go . I'm just thinking it's hard to cut a chain with a sword . I can see how the telescoping of certain plotlines might lead to a maimed Jaimie under Brienne's escort . Kinda hope I'm wrong , but either way I'll trust to the showrunners[/spoiler]

[spoiler]I liked how he gave Brienne some insults in this episode, since it reflects the book.  Hopefully, they're allowed to do a little journeying and have their epic battle first.[/spoiler]